Research progress of cable-driven flexible manipulator and its application in agricultural robots

doi:10.12398/j.issn.2096-7217.2024.04.007

Abstract

Abstract:

Cable-driven parallel robots have become a hot research topic in the field of robotics in recent years due to the characteristics of simple structure， small motion inertia， reconfigurability， and fast response speed， etc. The cable-driven flexible manipulator provides a certain adaptability and softness for operation due to the flexibility and elasticity of driving cable，and consequently it can achieve good dynamic interaction between the operating objects and the manipulators， and improve the ability to prevent broken loss coupling， which has also attracted widespread attention from researchers in the field of agricultural robotics. Due to the working environment of agricultural picking robots has the characteristics of unstructured and uncertainty， and most of the fruit outer skin is fragile and easy to damage， the requirements for picking robots that come into directly contacted with the fruits are stricter， ensuring stable grasping without damaging the fruits. In order to achieve efficient and precise operations of picking robots， lightweight and flexible end execution agencies that interact with biological friendly interaction are key theoretical technologies that urgently need to be broken through. This article first elaborates on the characteristics and development overview of cable-driven flexible manipulators with commercial application prospects. Then， the research progress of the theory such as the design， modeling and control of cable-driven flexible robotics at home and abroad is reviewed in detail. Further the typical application development of cable-driven flexible robots in the field of physical rehabilitation and dexterous grabbing is outlined. A detailed analysis is conducted on the significance of the application of cable-driven flexible manipulators in the field of agricultural picking， and the current research status of cable-driven flexible manipulators in tomato picking， apple picking， strawberry picking， and blackberry picking. Aiming at the problems of low picking accuracy， poor versatility， high cost， damage and low picking efficiency of cable-driven flexible manipulator in agricultural picking at the present stage， it is pointed out that in the future， the commercialization of cable-driven flexible manipulator needs to make innovations in agricultural machinery and agronomy collaboration， modular and reconfigurable design， improving interaction safety， multi-sensor integration， picking sequence planning and strong robust control in this study and it provides new ideas and methods for the design of mechanized non-destructive picking mechanisms for fruits and vegetables.

Key words: cable-driven flexible manipulator, agricultural robots, picking, tomatoes, apple, strawberries, blackberry

CLC Number:

WEI Huiling, LIANG Chengbin, WANG Jinhai, CHEN Mingyou, LUO Lufeng. Research progress of cable-driven flexible manipulator and its application in agricultural robots[J]. Journal of Intelligent Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 5(4): 95-106.

Figures/Tables 9

Figure 1 Design prototype of cable-driven flexible manipulator

Figure 2 Modelling prototype of cable-driven flexible manipulator

Figure 3 Cable-driven robotic in the field of agile operation

Figure 4 Cable-driven tomato picking robot

Figure 5 Super redundant cable-driven continuous picking robot

Figure 6 Cable-driven apple picking robot

Figure 7 Cable-driven gripper for strawberry picking

Figure 8 Cable-driven soft gripper for blackberry picking

Table 1 Comparison of relevant characteristics of different types of picking manipulator

性能参数	类型
性能参数	刚性机械手	气动软体机械手	绳驱柔性机械手
结构特点	刚度高、笨重	刚度低、较笨重	可变刚度、轻量化
自由度	少	无限多	多
柔顺性	低	高	高
灵活性	低	较高	高
安全性	低	高	高
工作环境	结构化	结构化和非结构化	结构化和非结构化
建模难易	容易	困难	较容易
控制难易	容易	不易	较容易
传动效率	高	低	较高
操作对象	固定尺寸	可变尺寸	可变尺寸
输出力	大	小	可变

References 67

1	LANGOWSKI J K A， SHARMA P， SHOUSHTARI A L. In the soft grip of nature ［J］.Science Robotics， 2020， 5（49）： 1-3.
2	KANEKO M， PAETSCH W. Input-dependent stability of joint torque control of tendon-driven robot hands ［J］. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics， 1992， 39（2）： 96-104.
3	MANTI M， HASSAN T， PASSETTI G， et al. A bioinspired soft robotic gripper for adaptable and effective grasping ［J］. Soft Robotics， 2015， 2（3）： 107-116.
4	TAN N， GU X Y， REN H L. Design， characterization and applications of a novel soft actuator driven by flexible shafts ［J］. Mechanism and Machine Theory， 2018， 122： 197-218.
5	ZHANG P， CHEN W C， TANG B. From two-dimensional to three-dimensional： Diversified bending modality of a cable-driven actuator and its grasping characteristics ［J］. Soft Robotics， 2022， 9（6）： 1154-1166.
6	DONG H， ASADI E， QIU C， et al. Grasp analysis and optimal design of robotic fingertip for two tendon-driven fingers ［J］. Mechanism and Machine Theory， 2018， 130： 447-462.
7	CAMARILLO D B， MILNE C F， CARLSON C R， et al. Mechanics modeling of tendon-driven continuum manipulators ［J］. IEEE Transactions on Robotics， 2008， 24（6）： 1262-1273.
8	PU S W， CHANG H T， CHANG J Y. Modeling and development of tension force measurement system for cable-driven hand exoskeleton robot ［C］//2015 IEEE International Conference on Advanced Intelligent Mechatronics， 2015.
9	MIN S， YI S. Development of cable-driven anthropomorphic robot hand ［J］. IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters， 2021， 6（2）： 1176-1183.
10	BACKUS S B， DOLLAR A M. An adaptive three-fingered prismatic gripper with passive rotational joints ［J］. IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters， 2016， 1（2）： 668-675.
11	ABEACH A， NEFTI M S， DAVIS S. Design of a variable stiffness soft dexterous gripper ［J］. Soft Robotics， 2017， 4（3）： 1-11.
12	LOVCHIK C S， DIFTLER M A. The robonaut hand： A dexterous robot hand for space ［C］// Proceedings 1999 IEEE international conference on robotics and automation （Cat. No. 99 CH36288C）. IEEE， 1999， 2： 907-912.
13	POTRATZ J， YANG J Z， ABDEL-MALEK K， et al. A light weight compliant hand mechanism with high degrees of freedom ［J］. Journal of Biomechanical Engineering， 2005， 127： 934-945.
14	WU L J， ANDRADE M J， SAHARAN L K， et al. Compact and low-cost humanoid hand powered by nylon artificial muscles ［J］. Bioinspiration and Biomimetics， 2017， 12（2）： 026004.
15	PALLI G， NATALE C， MAY C， et al. Modeling and control of the twisted string actuation system ［J］. IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics， 2013， 18（2）： 664-673.
16	PALLI G， HOSSEINI M， MELCHIORRI C. Twisted string actuation with sliding surfaces ［C］// 2016 IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems， Daejeon， Korea， 2016： 260-265.
17	WISTE T， GOLDFARB M. Design of a simplified compliant anthropomorphic robot hand ［C］// 2017 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation， Singapore， 2017（1）： 3433-3438.
18	HAM K， HAN J， PARK Y J. Soft gripper using variable stiffness mechanism and its application ［J］. International Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufacturing， 2018， 19（4）： 487-494.
19	LI C， GU X， REN H. A cable-driven flexible robotic grasper with lego-like modular and reconfigurable joints ［J］. IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics， 2017， 22（6）： 2757-2767.
20	DONG H， ASADI E， QIU C， et al. Geometric design optimization of an under-actuated tendon-driven robotic gripper ［J］. Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing， 2018， 50： 80-89.
21	TANG X T， LI K， LIU Y X， et al. A general soft robot module driven by twisted and coiled actuators ［J］. Smart Materials and Structures， 2019， 28（3）： 035019.
22	WANG R X， ZHANG X M， ZHU B L. Topology optimization of a cable-driven soft robotic gripper ［J］. Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization， 2020， 62（5）： 2749-2763.
23	J-Y NAGASE， WAKIMOTO S， SATOH T， et al. Design of a variable-stiffness robotic hand using pneumatic soft rubber actuators ［J］. Smart Materials and Structures， 2011， 20： 105015.
24	GIORELLI M， RENDA F， FERRI G， et al. A feed-forward neural network learning the inverse kinetics of a soft cable-driven manipulator moving in three-dimensional space ［C］// IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems， Tokyo， Japan， 2013： 5033-5039.
25	CHEN F F， XU W J， ZHANG H Y， et al. Topology optimized design， fabrication and characterization of a soft cable-driven gripper ［J］. IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters， 2018， 3（3）： 2463-2470.
26	WU Q， YI Z L， WANG H Q， et al. Design and experiment of a soft gripper based on cable-driven continuum structures ［C］// Proceedings of the 2021 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Biomimetics， December 27-31， 2021， Sanya， China.
27	CHEN T R， ZHAO X W， MA G C， et al. Design of 3D-printed cable driven humanoid hand based on bidirectional elastomeric passive transmission ［J］. Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering， 2021， 34（1）： 1-11.
28	王国庆，张启先，李大寨，等. 基于抓持稳定度的多指灵巧手抓持控制［J］. 航空学报， 1997， 18（3）： 294-298.
	WANG Guoqing， ZHANG Qixian， LI Dazhai， et al. Grasping control of the dexterous hand based on the degree of stability of grasping ［J］. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica， 1997， 18（3）： 294-298.
29	何平，金明河，刘宏，等. 机器人多指灵巧手基关节力矩/位置控制系统的研究［J］. 机器人， 2002， 24（4）： 314-318.
	HE Ping， JIN Minghe， LIU Hong， et al. Study of position and torque feedback control system of multi-fingered dexterous robot hand ［J］. Robot， 2002， 24（4）： 314-318.
30	FIROUZEH A， PAIK J. Grasp mode and compliance control of an under-actuated origami gripper using adjustable stiffness joints ［J］. IEEE-ASME Transactions on Mechatronics， 2017， 22（5）： 2165-2173.
31	GAO Y， HUANG X G， MANN I S， et al. A novel variable stiffness compliant robotic gripper based on Layer jamming ［J］. Journal of Mechanisms and Robotics， 2020， 12（5）： 051013.
32	QIAO S， ZHANG L， LI B， et al. Coupled bending inwards motion and control strategy analysis of a cable-driven underactuated finger ［J］. IEEE Access， 2021， 9： 133902-133913.
33	JEONG U， IN H K， CHO K J. Implementation of various control algorithms for hand rehabilitation exercise using wearable robotic hand ［J］. Intelligent Service Robotics， 2013， 6： 181-189.
34	IN H， LEE H， JEONG U， et al. Feasibility study of a slack enabling actuator for actuating tendon-driven soft wearable robot without pretension ［C］// IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation， Seattle， Washington， 2015： 1229-1234.
35	KAZEMINASAB S， HADI A， ALIPOUR K， et al. Force and motion control of a tendon-driven hand exoskeleton actuated by shape memory alloys ［J］. Industrial Robot-the International Journal of Robotics Research and Application， 2018， 45（5）： 623-633.
36	TOKUJI O. Computer control of multijointed finger system for precise object-handling ［J］. IEEE Transactions on Systems， Man， and Cybernetics， 1982， 12（3）： 289-299.
37	JACOBSEN S C， WOOD J E， KNUTTI D F， et al. The UTAH/MIT dextrous hand： Work in progress ［J］. The International Journal of Robotics Research， 1984， 3（4）： 21-50.
38	MATTHEW T M， J.KENNETH S， JOEY K P. Robot hands and the mechanics of manipulation ［M］. MIT Press， Cambridge， USA， 1985： 3-93.
39	TUFFIELD P， ELIAS H. The shadow robot mimics human actions ［J］. Industrial Robot： An International Journal， 2003， 30（1）： 56-60.
40	DESHPANDE A D， XU Z， WEGHE M， et al. Mechanisms of the anatomically correct testbed hand ［J］. IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics， 2013， 18（1）： 238-250.
41	MISHRA A K， DOTTORE E D， SADEGHI A， et al. SIMBA： Tendon-driven modular continuum arm with soft reconfigurable gripper ［J］. Frontiers in Robotics and AI， 2017， 4（4）： 1-10.
42	中华人民共和国国家统计局. 2022中国统计年鉴［M］. 北京：中国统计出版社， 2022.
43	刘继展，李智国，李萍萍. 番茄采摘机器人快速无损作业研究［M］. 北京：科学出版社， 2018.
44	BAC C W， VAN HENTEN E J， HEMMING J， et al. Harvesting robots for high-value crops： State-of-the-art review and challenges ahead ［J］. Journal of Field Robotics， 2014， 31（6）： 888-911.
45	MALDERA F， VIVALDI G A， IGLESIAS-CASTELLARNAU I， et al. Two almond cultivars trained in a super-high density orchard show different growth， yield efficiencies and damages by mechanical harvesting ［J］. Agronomy， 2021， 11： 1406.
46	孙凝晖，张玉成，石晶林. 构建我国第三代农机的创新体系［J］. 中国科学院院刊， 2020， 35（2）： 154-165.
	SUN Ninghui， ZHANG Yucheng， SHI Jinglin. Build innovation system of third generation of agricultural machinery in China ［J］. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences， 2020， 35（2）： 154-165.
47	赵春江. 智慧农业发展现状及战略目标研究［J］. 智慧农业， 2019， 1（1）： 1-7.
	ZHAO Chunjiang. State-of-the-art and recommended developmental strategic objectivs of smart agriculture ［J］. Smart Agriculture， 2019， 1（1）： 1-7.
48	VASCONEZ J P， KANTOR G A， AUAT CHEEIN F A. Humane-robot interaction in agriculture： A survey and current challenges ［J］. Biosystems Engineering， 2019， 179： 35-48.
49	RICHARD H. How robots are grasping the art of gripping ［J］. Nature， 2018， 557（7704）： 23-25.
50	LUO L， TANG Y， ZOU X， et al. Vision-based extraction of spatial information in grape cluster for harvesting robots ［J］. Biosystems Engineering， 2016， 151（11）： 90-104.
51	吴剑桥，范圣哲，贡亮，等. 果蔬采摘机器手系统设计与控制技术研究现状和发展趋势［J］. 智慧农业（中英文）， 2020， 2（4）： 17-40.
	WU Jianqiao， FAN Shengzhe， GONG Liang， et al. Research status and development direction of design and control technology of fruit and vegetable picking robot system ［J］. Smart Agriculture， 2020， 2（4）： 17-40.
52	蔡世波，陶志成，万伟伟，等. 机器人多指灵巧手的研究现状、趋势与挑战［J］. 机械工程学报， 2021， 57（15）： 1-14.
	CAI Shibo， TAO Zhicheng， WAN Weiwei， et al. Multi-fingered dexterous hands： From simplicity to complexity and simplifying complex applications ［J］. Journal of Mechanical Engineering， 2021， 57（15）： 1-14.
53	XIONG Y， PENG C， GRIMSTAD L， et al. Development and field evaluation of a strawberry harvesting robot with a cable-driven gripper ［J］. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture， 2019， 157： 392-402.
54	CERES R， PONS J L， JIMÉNEZ A R， et al. Design and implementation of an aided fruit-harvesting robot （Agribot）［J］. Industrial robot， 1998， 5（5）： 337-346.
55	刘成良，贡亮，苑进，等. 农业机器人关键技术研究现状与发展趋势［J］. 农业机械学报， 2022， 53（7）： 1-22， 55.
	LIU Chengliang， GONG Liang， YUAN Jin， et al. Current status and development trends of agricultural robots ［J］. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery， 2022， 53（7）： 1-22， 55.
56	MONTA M， KONDO N， TING K C. Harvesting end-effector for inverted single truss tomato production systems ［J］. Journal of the Japanese Society of Agricultural Machinery， 1998， 60（6）： 97-104.
57	MONTA M， KONDO N， TING K C. End-effectors for tomato harvesting robot ［J］. Artificial Intelligence Review， 1998， 13（1-3）： 11-25.
58	LING P P， EHSANI R， TING K C， et al. Sensing and end-effector for a robotic tomato harvester ［C］// ASAE Annual International Meeting， 2004： 1-12.
59	YESHMUKHAMETOV A， KOGANEZAWA K， YAMAMOTO Y. Design and kinematics of cable-driven continuum robot arm with universal joint backbone ［C］// IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Biomimetics. IEEE， 2018， December 12-15， 2018， Kuala Lumpur， Malaysia， 2444-2449.
60	YESHMUKHAMETOV A， KOGANEZAWA K， BURIBAYEV Z， et al. Development of continuum robot arm and gripper for harvesting cherry tomatoes ［J］. Applied Science， 2022， 12： 6922.
61	SILWAL A， DAVIDSON J R， KARKEE M， et al. Design， integration， and field evaluation of a robotic apple harvester ［J］. Journal of Field Robotics， 2017， 34（6）： 1140-1159.
62	DAVIDSON J R， MO C. Conceptual design of an end-effector for an apple harvesting robot ［C］// Conference on Automation Technology for Off-Road Equipment （ATOE）， Beijing， China. 2014， 18： 2021.
63	DAVIDSON J R， MO C. Mechanical design and initial performance testing of an apple-picking end-effector ［C］//ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition. American Society of Mechanical Engineers， 2015， 57397： V04 AT 04A011.
64	XIONG Y， FROM P J， ISLER V O. Design and evaluation of a novel cable-driven gripper with perception capabilities for strawberry picking robots ［C］// 2018 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation （ICRA）， May 21-25， 2018， Brisbane， Australia，7384-7391.
65	XIONG Y， GE Y Y， GRIMSTAD L， et al. An autonomous strawberry-harvesting robot： Design， development， integration， and field evaluation ［J］. Journal of Field Robotics， 2020， 37（2）： 202-224.
66	GUNDERMAN A L， COLLINS J， MYER A， et al. Tendon-driven soft robotic gripper for blackberry harvesting ［J］. IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters， 2022， 7（2）： 2652-2659.
67	高国华，董增雅，孙晓娜，等. 基于3D打印的柔性机械手研制及试验研究［J］. 智慧农业， 2019， 1（1）： 85-95.
	GAO Guohua， DONG Zengya， SUN Xiaona， et al. Development and test of a flexible manipulator based on 3D printing ［J］. Smart Agriculture， 2019， 1（1）： 85-95.

[1]	LI Jianping, LI Shaobo, YANG Xin, ZHANG Kuo, XIE Jinyan, LIU Shuteng, JIANG Zunhao, ZHANG Zhu, WANG Peng. Research progress on intelligent mechanization technology and equipment for apple orchard production management [J]. Journal of Intelligent Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 5(4): 66-83.
[2]	WANG Yuanhong, YANG Zhiming, WANG Qi, LU Jinzhu, GAO Junfeng. Design and experiment of tea bud recognition method and light source of recognition system based on YOLOv5-SPD [J]. Journal of Intelligent Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 5(3): 33-43.
[3]	WEI Tangwei, ZHANG Jincheng, WANG Jing, ZHOU Qingyan. Study of tea buds recognition and detection based on improved YOLOv7 model [J]. Journal of Intelligent Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 5(2): 42-50.
[4]	Jieli Duan, , Zhaorui Wang, Lei Ye, Zhou Yang, , . Research progress and development trend of motion planning of fruit picking robot arm [J]. Journal of Intelligent Agricultural Mechanization, 2021, 2(2): 7-17.